Author: Prof. Dr. Besnik ALIAJ, Dr. Ledio ALLKJA
Affiliation: POLIS University
Abstract
Albania has gone through different reforms of decentralization and territorial
administrative since the 1990s. Especially after 2013, these reforms have reshaped the layout
of the local territorial administration in Albania. The outcomes of these reforms nevertheless remain questionable. Additionally, considering the EU integration process, the regionalization reform and the regional development reform are still in a critical juncture. This paper analyses the main events during the territorial administrative reform and the regionalization process in Albania. Its analysis tries to highlight the main issues and some recommendations for future action to deepen decentralization and improve local governance in Albania. This is done by comprehensive analysis of the reform based on research and contribution of POLIS University 1 and Co-PLAN Institute for Habitat Development 2 as key local stakeholders. In addition, the Albanian case (Western Balkan Countries) is compared to 2 other case studies of formerly centralized economies (Eastern-Europe) with relatively similar historic stability problematics, economic background, and country/population size, but with geographic location differences (South, North, East) and other differences, such as with regard European integration progress. This includes Estonia (Baltic Countries) and Moldova (Eastern Partnership Countries). Then the comparison is done via i) Local administrative reform; ii) Regionalization and regional development; iii) Analysis of the reform and its challenges; iv) and a matrix-based qualitative conclusion. Albanian case includes desk and field work, while Estonian and Moldavian cases are based on desk research.
References:
Aliaj, B., 2008. Misteri i Gjashtë - Cili është kurthi që mban peng zhvillimin dhe integrimin e ekonomisë shqiptare me botën moderne? (The Sixth Mistery - What is the Trap that holds back the Development and the Integration of the Albanian Economy in the Modern World?). Tiranë: POLIS Press.
Aliaj, B., Dhamo, S. & Shutina, D., 2009. Midis Vakumit dhe Energjisë (Between Vacuum and Energy). Tiranë: POLIS Press.
Aliaj, B., Janku, E., Allkja, L. & Dhamo, S., 2014. Albania 2030 Manifesto: A National Spatial De- velopment Vision. Tiranë: POLIS Press
Allkja, L. (2020). Unraveling the complexity of Europeanization of spatial planning systems, the case of Albania [Dissertation, Technische Universität Wien]. https://doi.org/10.34726/ hss.2020.84704 https://repositum.tuwien.at/handle/20.500.12708/16029
Autoritati Publice Locale (2010). - Government of Moldova Archived from the original on 28 August 2010. Retrieved in 2010.
Baldersheim, Harald, Michal Illner, and Audun Offerdal. 1996. Local Democracy and the Process- es of Transformation in East-Central Europe. Boulder: Westview Press.
Bresser-Pereira, Luiz Carlos (2004) - Democracy and Public Management Reform. Oxford: Ox- ford University Press.
Brusis, Martin. 2001. Institution Building for Regional Development: A Comparison of the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia. In J. Beyer, J. Wielgohs, and H. Wiesenthal, eds., Successful Transitions: Political Factors of Socioeconomic Progress in Postsocialist Countries. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Co-PLAN, 2014, Rajonalizimi i Shqiperise – Reforma qeverisese, administrative dhe territoriale qe i duhet Shqiperise ne nivel rajonal. Co-PLAN, Instituti per Zhvillimin e Habitatit
CUATM (2019), Clasificatorul unitatilor administrative-territorial, Retrieved from the original 2019.
Ermurachi Adrian 2022 - The first steps in implementation of the local public administration reform. Commentary: https://www.ipn.md/en/the-first-steps-in-implementation-of-the-local- public-7978_1093937.html
Haldusreform.fin.ee 2017 (in Estonian) - Vabariigi Valitsuse määruse, Haanja valla, Misso valla, Mõniste valla, Rõuge valla ja Varstu valla osas haldusterritoriaalse korralduse ja Vabariigi Val- itsuse 3. aprilli 1995. a määruse nr 159, Eesti territooriumi haldusüksuste nimistu kinnitamine muutmine eelnõu seletuskiri
Hooghe, L. et al. (2016), Measuring Regional Authority: A Postfunctionalist Theory of Govern- ance, Oxford University Press.
Groenland, Edward.; (2014) - Employing the Matrix Method as a Tool for the Analysis of Qual- itative Research Data in the Business Domain, SSRN 2014 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers. cfm?abstract_id=2495330
Groenland, E. A. G. (2014). - The problem analysis for empirical studies. International Journal of Business and Globalization. 2014.
Gordon, W., & Langmaid, R. (1988). Qualitative market research. A practitioner’s and buyer’s guide. Farnhem, United Kingdom: Gower Publishing.
Rivo Noorkõiv (2021) – How Estonia’s reforms empowered local government, retrieved from https://decentralization.gov.ua/en/news/13820
Imami, F., Bejko, A., Shutina, D., (2018) Challenges of Regional Development in Albania, Annual Review of Territorial Governance in Albania, I, 2018, Page 08-23
GoA, 2016. National Strategy for Development and Integration, Tiranë, Albania: Qendra e Boti- meve Zyrtare.
PM, 2013. Programi i Qeverisë 2013 - 2017 [The Government Program 2013 - 2017], Tiranë: Këshilli i Ministrave.
Mehta, Vinod (2000). - Reforming Administration in India. Har-Anand Publications. ISBN 9788124107058.Pesti, Cerlin; Randma-Liiv, Tiina (2018). - “Estonia” @ Thijs, Nick,; Hammer- schmid, Gerhard,; (eds). Public administration characteristics and performance in EU 28. Lux- embourg: Publication office of EU. ISBN 9789279904530.
OECD (2019), Making Decentralisation Work: A Handbook for Policy-Makers, OECD Multi-lev- el Governance Studies, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://dx.doi.org/10.1787/g2g9faa7-en.
Shutina, D., Toto, R., Aliaj, B., 2012, Roli dhe Kompetencat e Qarkut dhe te institucioneve te tjera (mbeshtetese) lidhur me zhvillimin rajonal, in Politikberes apo Politikndjekes 2- Analiza dhe Re- komandime per qeverisjen terriotriale ne Shqiperi, Co-PLAN dhe POLIS, Tirane.
Shutina, D (2019) Territorial Rescaling for Polycentrc Governance: the case of Albania. https:// issuu.com/polisuniversity/docs/dritan_shutina_phd_thesis_28februar
Toska, M., Bejko, A., (2018) Territorial Administrative Reform and the Decentralization Strategy – Progress towards the Desired Objectives after a Governing Mandate, Annual Review of Territo- rial Governance in Albania, I, 2018, Page 69-83
Toto R (2010) “Rajonalizimi i Shqiperise perkundrejt Reformes Territoriale”, in Toto and Shutina (eds) (2010) “Politikendjekes apo Politikeberes!” Botime Afrojdit, Tirane
United Nations 1996 (DDSMS and UNDP), Report of the United Nations Global Forum on Inno- vative Policies and Practices in Local Governance, Gothenburg, Sweden, 23-27 September 1996, ref St/Tcd/Ser.E/46,
UNDP 1997, Decentralized Governance Programme: Strengthening Capacity for People -Cen- tered Development, Management Development and Governance Division, Bureau for Develop- ment Policy, September 1997
UNDP (1998), Factors to Consider in Designing Decentralized Governance Policies and Pro- grammes to Achieve Sustainable People -Centered Development, Management Development and Governance Division, February 1998,
United Nations’ Economic and Social Council (2005) - “Bottom-up Approaches and Methodol- ogies to Develop Foundations and Principles of Public Administration: The Example of Crite- ria-Based Organizational Assessment”. Document presented to Committee of Experts on Public Administration, Fourth session, New York, 4-8 April 2005 (E/C.16/2005/3).
Valner, Sulev. (2017) Administrative Reform 2017 in Estonia - Collection of Articles, decisions, backgrounds, implementation - Editor: Sulev Valner, English translation: Refiner Translations Translation consultant: Ave Viks, Ministry of Finance in Estonia, 2017, ISBN 978-9949-549-93-1
